Roberts continued to affirm his faith in the divine origins of. Was joseph smiths vivid and highly imaginative mind as. Roberts told his daughter, elizabeth skolfield, that a book of mormon study was written for presentation to the twelve and the presidency, not for publication 18 as with book of mormon difficulties. The incident that really motivated roberts to become involved again in historical study and especially to reexamine the origins of the book of mormon was a letter from a young man in salina, utah, william e. Roberts and the book of mormon religious studies center. He was playing devils advocate for the purpose of inspiring church leadership to work on a better defense as critics typically point out, roberts was a lds apologist. The john the baptist event as a case study jenny webb independent scholar, and on this wise do i give the account.
In the document, roberts investigated the documents including view of the hebrews which joseph smith could have consulted in writing the book of mormon. Roberts continued to affirm his faith in the divine origins of the book of mormon until his death in 1933. Brigham henry roberts march, 1857 september 27, 1933 was a historian, politician, and leader in the church of jesus christ of latterday saints. Sep 01, 1985 this title is open to a misreading, and yet, is accurate. Robertss book of mormon activities, public and private, from 1922 when his problems study was complete until his death on 27 september 1933, reveals that every week of every month of those eleven years b.
Signature books, 1992, 377 pages, paperback, isbn 1560850272 incredible as it may seem to many latterday saints, brigham h. Roberts studies of the book of mormon this book contains manuscripts of roberts who was a general authority, author, and church historian in which he expresses some serious doubts about the authenticity of the book of mormon and frankly admits that joseph smith had a vivid enough imagination and the source material available to produce the book of mormon. Roberts told the brethren they had some serious problems, and the q15, just brushed him off and pressed on like nothing was wrong. Roberts was one of the most respected and wellknown lds historians. Studies of the book of mormon kindle edition by roberts. Riter, who, on august 22, 1921, wrote to the geologist and theologian apostle james e. This title is open to a misreading, and yet, is accurate. The following books and bound pamphlets are located in the safe. Studies of the book of mormon is a collection of essays written at the beginning of the 20th century though not published until 1985 by b. It was anticipated that the book would form the basis for a priesthood study manual. He listed more trenchant sayings from the book of mormon than from any source other than the bible. Increasingly teachers and church leaders at all levels are approached by latterday saints who have lost confidence in joseph smith and the basic miraculous. A study, roberts wrote many things in a book of mormon study that are obviously not his views, but are given as.
These short articles were geared towards the youth and young adults of the church. Mormon although madsen was aware of the study as evidenced by his. If the book of mormon is not historical, but rather a reflection of the misconceptions current in joseph smiths. Roberts and presents a synopsis of his rigorous lifetime study of the book of mormon. Roberts writings, and are vital to understanding what b. Roberts, the translation of the book of mormon, improvement era 9 april 1906. He published a popular sixvolume history of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church and also wrote studies of the book of mormonpublished posthumouslywhich discussed the validity of the book of mormon as an ancient. Roberts wrote the material contained in studies of the book of mormon to illustrate the positions that critics would take. A mormon general authoritys doubts about the authenticity. He made an excellent study of the environment and source material available to joseph smith in the 1820s. However, he was not satisfied with that work and later delved more deeply into other critical questions about book of mormon origins, which led him to a major analysis of view of the hebrews. View of the hebrews1823 book of mormon1829 very very similar. Divided into three parts the first part of studies of the book of mormon roberts deals with his quandry in attempting to answer five questions which were asked by a doctor who had read the book of mormon given to him by a friend. Roberts was preparing, writing, presenting, and publishing materials on the book of mormon.
View of the hebrews1823 book of mormon 1829 very very similar. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading studies of the book of mormon. Roberts was the first mormon apologist, president of the first quorum of seventies and mormon church historian. Is there an ebook or pdf of bh roberts studies of the book. Studies of the book of mormon kindle edition by roberts, b. Roberts was additionally recognized as the mormon churchs most accomplished scriptorian of his day. Im not aware of any digital copies, but it was a major factor for me. As far as your question goes, its probably the best secular way of describing joseph smiths. Roberts argued that his study was of very great importance since it. It is altogether probable that these two bookspriests wonders of nature and providence, 1824. A study in the first part, book of mormon difficulties. Roberts wrote a man would get nearer to god by abiding by book of mormon precepts than by any other book. Roberts 18571933, a general authority of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints lds church, which examine the validity of the book of mormon as a translation of an ancient american source. Roberts studies of the book of mormon and mckays no man knows my history are the definitive works on early mormon church history.
Roberts thought, its curious the the ces letter conveniently fails to mention them. A performative approach to the book of ether concurrent sessions 2. A mormon general authoritys doubts about the authenticity of the book of mormon incredible as it may seem to many latterday saints, brigham h. Top ten books the lds mormon church doesnt want you to. Roberts is revered in mormon history as one of the mormon churchs greatest theologians and historians. Roberts approached the book of mormon from many different perspectives, all adding to his conviction that it was authentic scripture. I am forwarding you with this mail an introductory chapter to a work of mine which is in typewritten form under the title book of mormon study.
Among readers who came to the book of mormon with hard, skeptical assumptions, b. Book of mormon studies regarded as the foremost mormon theologian of his day, roberts was given a letter with questions about the book of mormon from a skeptic to answer. He was capacitated by temperament and equipped by study for penetrating analysis. Is there an ebook or pdf of bh roberts studies of the. Bradley independent scholar, the book of mormons function as oral scripture. The most common nonlds explanation for the book of mormon is the socalled spaulding theory, of which there at least four variations. But, persists the critic, we cannot recover the precise historical truth about a moses or a jesus. Western historical quarterly, richard sherlock here for the first.
Roberts and the book of mormon book of mormon central. These sayings, he believed, were comparable in their edge and insight not only to biblical but also to hindu and chinese classics. Roberts was a general authority, member of the mormon churchs first council of. Roberts has 90 books on goodreads with 2442 ratings. Bh roberts on book of mormon historicity was he an early adopter of the inspired but not historical approach to the book of mormon. Grant to help answer questions from a man who had written to the church. Roberts 18571933, an lds general authority widely considered mormonisms greatest apologist and historian, 1 expressed the grave doubt that the book of mormon is a translation of ancient. Literary analysis provides useful tools in the study of sacred texts, including the book of mormon. The study is sometimes confused with a shorter, 145page paper entitled book of mormon difficulties which is what b. Roberts considered the evident parallels between the book of mormon and ethan smiths view of the hebrews, a book that predated the mormon scripture by seven years. B h roberts and the book of mormon truman g madsen introduction by its own account the book of mormon is for doubters it an nounces on its title page a clear purpose for all the hard labor of preserving records to the convincing of thejewahejewthejew and gentile that jesus is the christ the eternal god that statement presupposes that there would be serious and searing doubt in the world and. Bh roberts on book of mormon historicity the mormon memo. Roberts of the first council of the seventy, compiled by ben r. I did read bh robert s book that you mention and i think robert s was posing the question hypothetically and then playing devils advocate answering it.
This book should be a requirement for anyone studying the book of mormon. This has about 10 excellent essays on various studies of book of mormon subjects. The roberts manuscripts represent a compelling case study of the ageold tension between religious faith and rational thought. Origin of new world peoples view of the hebrews and the book of mormon claim that the hebrews occupied the whole extent of the american continents and that this idea was very generally obtained throughout new england. Roberts, in his critical study of the book of mormon, pointed out how future critics might make use of this. When they say they saw and heard god, they saw and heard god. Check out roberts book, studies of the book of mormon b. Bh roberts predicted that if church leaders did not address the historical problems of church origins and possible anachronisms in the book of mormon, these problems would eventually undermine the faith of the youth of the church. I read a copy which i received from the salt lake county library system. Studies of the book of mormon, edited by brigham d. Roberts initially wrote by way of committee assignment from elder james e.
Robertss studies of the book of mormon the dialogue journal. A study, was a 141page manuscript written in response to a series of questions by an inquirer, referred to roberts by church president heber j. Moreover, at many junctures of his life he had profound. Roberts indepth studies of book of mormon origins led him to doubt the authenticity of the book. The overwhelming consensus of the authors is the book of mormon is still true, but must be regarded as a fictional story as it does not in anyway fit archeologically, culturally or in. Roberts s first report, in december 1921, was a 141page paper entitled book of mormon difficulties. Roberts of the first council of the seventy wrote a fourpart series in the improvement era focusing on alma the youngers counsel to his three sons. Roberts intended his book to represent the summation of his thinking on the gospel. When roberts confessed that he had no answer for some of the difficulties, and the general authorities chose to ignore them, roberts produced a book of mormon study, a treatise of more than 400 pages.
Roberts parallel of the book of mormon to view of the hebrews. B h roberts and the book of mormon truman g madsen introduction by its own account the book of mormon is for doubters it an nounces on its title page a clear purpose for all the hard labor of preserving records to the convincing of thejewahejewthejew and gentile that. Roberts saw the book of mormon as a well of aphorisms. Reflecting his talent for combining history and theology, b. When this parliament denied his request, he went to the public press in an effort to win support for the cause of the church.
He states a case against the book of mormon in tough terms. Roberts and the book of mormon byu scholarsarchive. The book of mormon refuted by lds apostle b h roberts. Roberts asserted that the authenticity of the restoration must stand or fall on the truth of joseph smiths claim that the book of mormon was the history of an ancient people inscribed on a cache of gold plates. Roberts also compared the book of mormon with ethan smiths view of. This same presumption, with the book of mormon in the foreground, led roberts to see to it that the modern church came to repossess its cradle. Moreover, at many junctures of his life he had profound personal reasons and emotional and spiritual stresses which might have led a man of lesser integrity to discard wholesale his religious heritage. What lloyd saw was a book of mormon study, a 300page document in which roberts sets forth his reasons for concluding that the book of mormon was not of divine origin. Roberts, revered lds historian, general authority, president of the quorum of the seventy, and faithful to the church throughout his life, sets out to answer a series of tough questions about mormonisms key book of scripture he even comes up with questions of his own, demonstrating his dedication to a thorough examination. Roberts on the view of the hebrews parallels with the book of mormon emphasis mine.
Studies of the book of mormon, unpublished until 1985, is his three part study of the historicity of the book of mormon. The book of mormon reinstates all authentic modes of religious awareness. Roberts 18571933, an lds general authority widely considered mormonisms greatest apologist and historian, 1 expressed the grave doubt that the book of mormon is a translation of ancient scripture. In the early 1920s, roberts was asked by the first presidency of the. For the author, three transforming events that enhanced her study of the book of mormon included reading the book in earnest as a complex and masterful literary text, the entrance of the spirit into her study of the book, and a prayerful desire to experience the great change of heart described. He also was a member of the first council of seventy 18881933. Robertss first report, in december 1921, was a 141page paper entitled book of mormon difficulties. Roberts answers with the book of mormon, the gospel has a history and the life required in it is based upon the facts of that history twl, 14. Deseret book company 1948 contains the last seven discourses delivered by elder roberts. Roberts constructed the possible argument that the book of mormon relied upon ethan smiths book.
Ever since bh roberts writings about challenges facing the book of mormon were finally published in 1985, people have argued about whether or not he had lost faith. Robertss most popular book is studies of the book of mormon. Roberts thought, its curious the the ces letter conveniently fails to. Roberts, higher criticism and the book of mormon, improvement era 14 june 1911. Roberts and book of mormon scholarship by davis bitton. Available for the first time fifty years after the authors death, studies of the book of mormon presents this respected church leaders investigation into. Moreover, at many junctures of his life he had profound personal reasons and emotional and spiritual stresses which might have led a man of lesser integrity to. Although roberts continued to testify to the truth of the book of mormon, a foundational work of mormonism, he also wrote three studies, unpublished until 1985, that wrestled with book of mormon problems. Jun 05, 2011 the book of mormon refuted by lds apostle b h roberts. A dynamic, interactive, webfriendly presentation of the book of mormon. Roberts wrote three papers that listed parallels between the book of mormon and the second edition 1825 of ethan smiths view of the hebrews. His sixvolume comprehensive history of the church is still one of the most respected works of mormon history.
1108 1324 1143 410 1107 1026 196 618 1421 593 73 1444 298 829 1026 663 731 444 173 1370 529 570 1422 44 261 946 1448 572 170 685 1219 230 161 32 531 1374 131 607 1017 229 1340